Bad Half Butterfly Guard (Pass Prevention)

Three techniques to counter the under-over pass from the bad “half butterfly guard” position.

My instructor Eduardo emphasizes the first two guard returns because they develop skills he considers among the most important for a good open guard: creating space by shrimping, creating space extending your body, and circling the hooks back in. You’ll see him use these over and over again every time he fights.

(Also available on Youtube and Revver.)

Extra Details

Shrimping hook return: You can grab your foot and pull it in front of their face if you need to. Keep your hand near your foot as you bring your butterfly hook in and it’ll give you a little safe path to get the underhook too.

Bridging hook return: You can see this movement—crunch then explode—in a lot of situations and from a lot of grips and guards. “Bridging” may be the wrong word to describe it though; you’re not just lifting your hips, but also extending your body to push them with your knees.

Shrimp to crucifix: I failed to mention that you don’t just want to push their head to the side but also down to the ground so they can’t posture up and turn towards you.

Please let me know what you think through the comments here or on any of the video sites (Revver, Vimeo, Youtube) or through my contact form.

Jeff Rockwell Interview

Jeff Rockwell is a brown belt under Ricardo de la Riva and runs a DLR affiliate school, teaching BJJ and MMA at LionHeart Fitness and Mixed Martial Arts in State College, PA. You can find the address and schedule at myspace.com/rockjitsu.

Jeff Rockwell and Ricardo de la Riva

Jeff Rockwell and Ricardo de la Riva.

How did you get into BJJ?

I got into the martial arts the same way a lot of people my age did: I saw Bruce Lee and I wanted to be just like him. My parents never really wanted me to get into martial arts as a kid, though, as they thought it would encourage me to fight. So I just watched movies, read books, and dreamed of defeating a room full of thugs with my nunchucku. Once I finally left home for college, I decided to find a place to start training. Luckily for me, there was a Jeet Kune Do club right on campus, so I jumped right in and joined up. Working with them led me to an actual school in Maryland, where I trained for several years. It was great, we trained a bit of everything – boxing, Muay Thai kickboxing, Jun Fan, kali, silat, sambo, shootwrestling, and jiu-jitsu. So I got exposed to a lot of ideas and styles. There was very little sparring or live rolling, however, so while I learned a lot, the timing under pressure just wasn’t there.

I gravitated towards jiu-jitsu and thai-boxing, and I started training at another gym as well. This gym was a Rigan Machado affiliate, and it was there I really got baptized in the jiu-jitsu fires… I quickly learned that all the leglocks and neck cranks in the world don’t help you if you can’t escape the side control of a seasoned jiu-jitsu practitioner. It was really tough…I got pretty discouraged at one point and actually gave it up for a few months. But the love of jiu-jitsu I had developed was deeper than the frustration, and when I went back, I found some very encouraging training partners who helped me through that period. Since then I have moved around the country a good bit and been at many different gyms, and I’m happy to say that I’ve never had to take more than a week or two off from training.

How have the demands on you changed since you started teaching at your gym?

Teaching full time is very demanding! In the mornings, I usually teach a private BJJ session for our MMA fighters, then I teach a lunchtime public BJJ class, then I lead a two-hour MMA team practice for our fighters, then I teach another public BJJ class in the evenings. On some days I squeeze in a private lesson for one of my students in there as well. I take four or five showers a day sometimes! I don’t have much down time these days, but I can’t complain, I love what I do.

Do you have any trouble balancing your personal development with teaching and running classes?

It is definitely a challenge to balance my personal development and that of my fighters and students. With the schedule I currently have, it’s pretty hard to find extra time for extra cardio, weightlifting, technical drilling, and other things I need to do to stay in competition shape. Plus, it is hard to keep up this pace and stay injury free. I am not that old (about to turn 33), but I feel like I am jumping from one injury to another these days. Nothing that keeps me off the mat completely, thank goodness, but enough to keep me from feeling I can train as hard as I would like to consistently. So that is annoying, but I just keep doing as much as I can, trying to get enough rest, and trying to find the perfect formula. I have really only been doing this job at this pace for a few months, and I am still figuring things out. I am optimistic that I’ll be able to find a good balance so I can continue to personally grow and compete at a high level, as well as teach others at this pace.

What’s the current makeup of your gym experience-wise?

We are still a fairly young gym, and we are primarily made up of white and blue belts at this point. A few of our blues are getting very close to purple belt level. In addition, our gym is really fortunate to have some of the best wrestlers in the country! It is not uncommon for us to have 5 or 6 Div. I All-Americans or even National Champions in our room at any given time, training BJJ, MMA, Boxing, or Thai boxing right alongside everyone else. They are incredible athletes with incredible work ethics, and they are a pleasure to train with. I learn just as much from them as they do from me, and everyone helps one another improve and evolve.

With all those wrestlers, have you seen any interesting examples of wrestling and BJJ, MMA, etc. blending together?

Absolutely! Off the top of my head, I have seen variations of the “anaconda” or “gator roll” choke come VERY naturally to the wrestlers I’ve worked with, along with the “Peruvian Necktie”… basically, anything with a front headlock. The wrestlers all wanted to choke people with those grips for years, so now that they are allowed to…it only takes a few sessions for them to start having fun with them.

What’s cool is that they are at such a high level that they will start making stuff up on their own. They understand how the body works and how to manipulate it, so I show them one move, and they end up figuring out 2 or 3 more positions to use it from, and I end up learning from them. Sometimes they make moves work in places that “BJJ Law” says that it shouldn’t!

It’s very interesting, as they all have different styles… some have speed and movement, some have crushing upper body holds, some even have the rare “heavy hips”… I am trying to get them to blend all of these together, while keeping in their different body types and personalities in mind.

What are the traits you look for in a good training partner or a good student?

Someone who is hungry to learn; someone who is willing to work very hard in training, but still laugh and have a good time; someone who is willing to drill the basics, over and over; someone who can easily adjust the “volume dial” of their training intensity up or down depending on who they are working with; someone who wants to teach others because they love jiu-jitsu, not because they want to feel superior.

What role has competition had in your training? Do you encourage your students to compete?

Competition has, and continues to, provide focus for my training. It’s easy to get caught up in the endless fancy variations of BJJ against the guys in your gym, but competition forces you to strip your game down to the bare bones and look at what you can make work against almost everyone, almost every time. It forces you to address your weaknesses and build a game plan around your strengths. Competition is the test at the end of the training semester to let you know how much you know and if you can apply what you’ve learned. Some people can get learn a lot in school never taking tests, but they are rare and very self motivated. Most people can benefit from having the type of focus that a competition brings. I never force my students to compete, but I definitely encourage it.

Which of your fighters should we be keeping an eye on? Who has matches coming up?

In the long run, everybody! We have such tough guys. In the near future, Paul Bradley and Phil Davis. Paul has made fantastic strides in his striking game recently, and has become a nightmare: a fantastic wrestler who wants to stay on his feet and knock you out. And he can, with either hand! He is extremely hard to take down, and extremely hard to submit. His jiu-jitsu game has taken some great leaps recently as well. In some ways, Paul takes his fighting more seriously than anyone.

Phil Davis has endless potential, and is a strange combination of showmanship and humility. It’s hard to believe he’s really only been training for about 6 months. Many things come very naturally to him… others he has to really put a lot of reps in before he feels he’s got it. I have seen this very thing discourage a lot of people who are so called “natural athletes”; they can’t stand to not be a master of everything on the first try. But not Phil, he digs in and stays after practice to do 50 more reps of whatever is bugging him that day. He comes early and stays late. He doesn’t want it to be “good enough”, he wants it to be “right”. He doesn’t just want to win, he wants to win with technique that will make people take notice. He knows how good he is already, and he knows how good he can be… but he also knows that it will take him a lot of hard work to really get there, and he is willing to eagerly listen to anyone who can help him become a better fighter. He has torn through amateur competition so far, and is getting ready to make waves in the pros. I don’t see a limit to how far he can go.

EVERYBODY at Lionheart has matches coming up! Our fighters don’t stay inactive for too long. Paul Bradley is fighting this weekend in Cleveland, and all of our fighters have fights lined up in the next few months.

What kind of loyalty do you expect from your students and what should they expect from you?

I always encourage my students to go train with other people and other gyms; as long as they promise to come back and show me any new tricks or positions they learned there! I always want my students to be exposed to as many different styles, philosophies, and techniques as possible, so they can see what is best for them. I try to show them as much as I can, even things I don’t personally use very much or prefer, but you can never know everything or even show all that you know, really. So it is best for them to be exposed to as many different points of view as they can. I am never worried about them leaving me for another gym. If that ever happens, whether for logistical or philosophical reasons, there are never any hard feelings. I always want people to feel like they are at home and getting the best training they can, in the best environment possible.

Techniques by Jeff:

Level of Detail

This is a useful yet very nerdy analogy that’s aided me when I’m teaching. It may help you when you’re trying to explain a new or complex technique to someone that you are worried won’t get it.

In video game programming, the level of detail of an object decreases as it moves further away and increases as you get closer. When something is partially concealed, they only render what you can see. Programmers can get away with this because they figure you won’t need every detail when something is far enough away (or not even in sight) and you can’t tell the difference.

You’ve likely seen this if you play video games. A tree across the map is just a blotch of green, then as you run forward it turns into a lumpy green pyramid, then it gets branches and finally it’s a complete tree. Or you see the tip of spaceship sticking out from around a corner, but as far as the game is concerned, that’s all there is to it and it’s not worth dealing with the rest yet.

Where this applies to teaching is in figuring out how much to simplify and when to add greater detail and complexity. When someone is a beginner or new to a technique, you can overload them by showing every detail and variation and counter and re-counter. These will be ignored or forgotten since they don’t have any foundation of experience to build on.

So what you do is scale it back. Teach them a simplified version of the technique. Give them the bare bones to start getting a feel for it. It may not be “the best” way to do the move but it’s what they’ve got to learn before they can process more details. Once they’ve got that level, move up to the next and flesh it out further.

Think of the students brain as a computer processor. It can only handle so much at once. You’ve got to give it the most important information first and make sure it’s in chewable amounts, otherwise it overloads and chokes. Start simple and ramp it up as needed.

You can visualize it by taking a technique and making an abstraction of it. Imagine there is an perfect way to do a move, in a Platonic idealism sense. Now imagine your perfect technique as an object, a sphere. You could have a progression of increasingly accurate representations, like this:

Levels of detail

(These spheres also lends themselves to a diamond polishing metaphor: you’re starting with a crude rock and through progressive refining and polishing you get the desired form.)

To give a specific example of this concept, look at how an armbar from mount is taught to a beginner versus how it’s done by someone with experience. With the beginner, you have their training partner stick their arms straight up into them. The beginner posts both hands on the chest, slides a knee up to the head, steps up with his other leg, stands to pass his leg over the head and falls back with the arm.

Is anyone with experience going to straighten both their arms like that? Are you going to want to be that loose and slow when you spin around the arm? Are you going to get that high to pass your leg over the head? No, but that doesn’t matter. At this point the beginner is still just learning the gross body movements and how to shift his weight and move his hips. Once he gets that, you can do a second pass and clean up the technique, making it tighter, smoother or faster and adding details.

A personal example is the difference between how I teach the reverse omoplata and how I do it. It wouldn’t make sense and they’d get information overload if I showed them my way. Instead I teach a simpler version first. That gets them familiar with it. They’ll have success with it for a bit but they’ll also start running into problems. Now that they have experience with it, I can give more details and they’ll see where they fit in, whereas before they wouldn’t have had the proper context.

What you started with and what you ended with may be very different beasts and yet they are fundamentally the same move, based on the same principles. What got you there was working up through lower levels of detail and complexity until you’re as close to the “ideal technique” as you can be.

Image from Level of Detail (Wikipedia).

BJJ Warm-ups and Exercise Videos

Been enjoying putting together exercises routines and running class warm-ups that are outside the standard running, push-ups, crunches and shrimping.

I really like ones that make me feel uncoordinated and off-balance at when I first try them. There’s probably some neurophysiology reasoning I could make up about the brain and body struggling to adapt to a new movement and how this develops reflexes and “body awareness” or whatever, but really they’re just fun.

Bonus points if the moves makes you look stupid. Get a room full of guys Indian leg wrestling or crab walking and you’ll put them in a more relaxed mood.

Here are the best drills I’ve found online so far.

Komodo Dragon Crawl

Monkey Run

Backward Dolphin

Armadillo

5 Partner Exercises

Individual Exercises

Milanimal Workout Series

Grappling: les bases. Les drills seul.

Les Drills à deux en JJB

Arte Suave – Andre Galvao

Open Door Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu Warm up

Questions to Ask Yourself and Things to Try

This list is a tool I made to help keep myself motivated. It’s split into two parts: questions to ask yourself and things to try. Together they give you something to be thoughtful and introspective about and something to get out there and do. The idea is to turn to it each week (or when you’re in a slump) and see if it can’t help you improve.

Try this:

Pick out a random question and give it serious thought. Be objective and honest with yourself. Write down your answer if you need to. Did you have any new ideas?

Pick a random thing to try. Follow the instructions as well as you can. Write notes on how it went. Did you learn anything new?

If you type up your answers to the questions or if you have an interesting experience trying one of the ideas, tell me about it here in the comments or by email.

Questions to Ask Yourself

How good is your hip movement on the bottom?

What part of your game needs the most work?

What position gives you the most trouble?

What do you need to improve next?

How good is your posture in guard?

How can you improve your diet?

Are you getting enough sleep?

Is there a move you “should know” that still gives you trouble?

How well can you open the closed guard?

What is your favorite position?

What submission do you have the most trouble escaping?

Do you keep fighting from your back when you could get to your knees?

Are you confident with your closed guard?

Could you keep playing the same game if you were less athletic?

How much of your current game will stay the same as you age?

Are you confident with your open guard?

What positions do you avoid that you shouldn’t?

What moves can you do on one side but not the other?

How many rounds can you go before you’re gassed?

If your armbar fails, where do you go from there?

Are your legs really too short for the triangle or are your mechanics off?

Do you do something that goes “against the rules” (e.g. submissions from bad positions)?

What was the last submission you got caught with?

What causes you the most frustration?

Are you ashamed to pull guard?

Do you train takedowns enough?

Can you do your favorite throw while moving in different directions?

Do you prefer to pass from knees or standing?

How good are your standing guard passes?

If you had to start over, what would you do differently?

Are you making the best use of your training time?

Are there “basic” moves you wish you were better at?

Are there moves you never tried because you worried they were “too advanced”?

How can you use less strength?

How can you use less flexibility?

How confident are you with the gi?

How confident are you without the gi?

How different are your gi and no-gi games?

Are you aggressive enough?

Are you relaxed enough?

Are you too passive?

Are you too defensive?

What parts of your game could you simplify?

What submissions do you never try?

Have you surprised yourself lately?

If your triangle fails, what’s your backup plan?

Why didn’t you do karate instead?

Do you hold your breath when you shouldn’t?

Do you know of a black belt with your body type to watch?

Do you use the omoplata much?

Do you have a favorite finish from each position?

Whose guard do you really admire?

What does your belt mean to you?

Why are you afraid of competing?

Are you still worried about self defense?

How good are your headlock escapes?

Is your guard “too open” and loose?

Do you have a “go to” move for each guard you use?

What’s your main attack from mount?

What is your worst skill?

How do you measure your performance?

How much have you improved in the last six months?

Where would you like to be in 6 months?

Do you really want to compete?

Can you visualize moves and positions as simple geometry?

Do you use the americana much?

How often do you get the cross collar choke from guard?

How good are your side control escapes?

How far can you push your endurance?

What is your proudest moment?

What do you regret?

How many of the people that started with you are still training?

Do you remember what it was like to be a white belt?

What would be the simplest and quickest move from each position?

Are you overlooking simpler solutions?

Do you do moves just because they look cool?

What is a “basic” technique?

How do you define the fundamentals?

Would doing things differently be wrong or just different?

Is there a move you always wished you could do better?

Are there moves you just never seem to remember when you need them?

How do you keep yourself motivated?

Are the health risks worth it?

Do you drill moves on both sides?

Do you really need that many instructionals?

Do you try a move in sparring the same day you drilled it?

Do you find drilling boring?

Do you put in enough repetitions?

How is your half guard?

Do you just stall in certain positions?

Are you always looking for the finish?

Do you worry that lower belts are catching up to you?

Is there something you always wished you were better at?

What part of competing makes you most nervous?

How can the last technique you learned fit into your game?

Do you have one really good training partner to work one-on-one with?

Do you need private lessons?

What sweeps and submissions go together?

What part of the mental game do you need to improve?

How do you deal with anxiety?

Are you afraid of losing?

Things to Try

Pick just one submission to focus on for a week.

Concentrate on how your hips are moving while sparring.

Find a way to make your hips as heavy as possible while passing.

Drill a sweep you didn’t like the first time you learned it.

Take two different positions and figure out how to transition between them.

Pick one position and work on it for a month.

Try a new move today.

Pick a move you don’t use enough and drill it before class for a week.

Draw a diagram of a move that explains its mechanics.

Write down how to do the last move you learned with as much detail as possible.

Draw a flowchart of the positions you use and how you transitions between them.

Try a new move just because it looks fun.

Almost let a white belt tap you today.

See how long you can hold a “strange” position while sparring.

Let people pass your guard so you can work on your escapes.

Pick your least favorite position and work on it.

Teach your favorite move to someone who doesn’t know it.

Put together a three move combination and drill it.

Fight from top as much as possible for a week.

Don’t close your guard in sparring today.

Find a “fancy” move and see if it really is that fancy.

Drill the escapes to the last submission you got caught in.

Make a combination of three guard passes that have you go over, under and around the legs.

Ask a lower belt for his perspective on something.

Try to stand up from guard more often.

Try to take the back from everywhere.

Watch and study higher belts sparring.

Figure out how much your game changes with and without the gi.

Stretch before and after training.

Play guard as much as possible for a week.

Replay a round of sparring in your head as you’re going to sleep.

“Steal” a good move from someone else.

Coach two white belts against each other.

Make your intentions obvious and see if you can still get the move.

Focus on controlling your breathing.

Set a faster pace than normal.

Set a slower pace than normal.

Move slowly and deliberately while sparring today.

Move fast and light with sparring today.

See how long you can hold mount.

See how many transitions you can do in one round.

Find a high level competitor with your body type and try to emulate him.

Stop halfway through a move and see how long you can maintain control.

Try a dumb move today.

Spar with your eyes closed.

Try sparring two people at once.

Hold knee-on-belly for as long as you can in sparring today.

Stand to pass guard this week.

Don’t use one of your arms today.

Work on your rear mount escapes.

Try holding side control on a balance ball to develop pressure.

Compare where you are now to where you were 6 months ago.

Try not using your arms at all while sparring today.

Drill level changes and penetration steps today.

Take a minute to do as many repetitions of the armbar from mount as possible.

Do a full round of sparring from under side control.

Train transitions instead of positions.

Figure out a way to improve your scramble.

Draw a picture of how you think of a certain movement.

Pick the toughest person at your gym and spar with them.

Only use moves you learned as a white belt today.

Put in extra repetitions on your bad side.

Be single-minded in going for what you learned and drilled in class today.

Fine tune your chokes with feedback from your training partner.

See how long you can hold the triangle position without finishing the submission.

Put yourself in submissions and see if you can get out.

Approach old moves like they’re completely new to you.